Division of Endocrinology, Department of Systems Medicine, University of Rome Tor Vergata, Rome, Italy.
Copyright © 2019 Korean Diabetes Association
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Study | Study design and setting | No. and category | CAN measures | CAN prevalence | Differences vs. NGT | CAN correlatesa |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Annuzzi et al. (1983) [ | Hospital diabetes clinic; Italy | 124 NGT, 62 IGT | DB | Not provided | No differences | Age, BMI |
Fujimoto et al. (1987) [ | Community-based study; USA (Japanese-American men) | 79 NGT, 72 IGT | DB | Not provided | No differences | Fasting glucose |
Gerritsen et al. (2000) [ | Hoorn study; the Netherlands | 288 NGT, 169 IGT | Short-term HRV, BRS, DB, LS, OH | Not provided | ↓SDNN | Age, antihypertensive drugsa |
Singh et al. (2000) [ | Framingham Heart Study; USA | 1,779 NFG, 56 IFG | Short-term HRV | Not provided | ↓SDNN, HF and LF. Differences no more present after adjusting for covariates | Fasting glucose |
Schroeder et al. (2005) [ | ARIC study; USA | 5,410 NFG, 3,561 IFG | Short-term HRV | Not provided | ↓RR interval and rMSSD at baseline. No differences in the rate of change in HRV | Fasting glucose (weak association at baseline) |
Perciaccante et al. (2006) [ | Hospital diabetes clinic; Italy | 20 control, 20 IFG, 20 IGT | 24 hr HRV | Not provided | ↓SDNN, low TP, and ↑LFnu in IFG and IGT | HOMA-I |
Stein et al. (2007) [ | Cardiovascular Health Study; USA | 536 NFG, 545 IFG | 24 hr HRV | Not provided | ↓RR interval, SDNN and TP in IFG subgroup 2 (fasting glucose 6.1–6.9 mmol/L) | Fasting glucose, metabolic syndrome componentsa |
Wu et al. (2007) [ | Population-based study; Taiwan | 983 NGT, 163 IFG, 188 IGT | Short-term HRV, DB, LS | Not provided | ↓SDNN and DB in IFG and IGT; ↓LS and HF in IGT; only IGT associated with LS, HF power and LF:HF after adjustment | Not provided |
Isak et al. (2008) [ | University clinic; Turkey | 25 NGT, 25 IGT | DB, LS, VM, OH, Handgrip, Sudomotor function | Not provided | No differences apart from in sympathetic skin response | Not provided |
Laitinen et al. (2011) [ | Finnish Diabetes Prevention Study; Finland | 268 IGT | DB, OH | 25% Abnormal DB, 6% abnormal OH | Not provided (no control group) | Age, BMI, waist, triglycerides (in men) |
Putz et al. (2013) [ | Hospital diabetes clinic; Hungary | 40 NGT, 75 IGT | DB, LS, VM, OH Handgrip test, Triangle index | IGT: 57.5% one abnormal test | ↓DB, Valsalva ratio, OH, handgrip test, and triangle index | Not provided |
Ziegler et al. (2015) [ | KORA S4 Study; Germany (55–74 yr) | 565 NGT, 336 IFG, 72 IGT, 151 IFG-IGT | 4 Out of 120 short-term HRV indices | NGT: 4.5% | 4 and 6 HRV measures more frequently abnormal in IFG and IFG-IGT, respectively | HR, BMI, hypertension, smoking, creatinine, drugs suppressing HRV as predictors of diminished HRVa |
IFG: 8.1% | ||||||
IGT: 5.9% | ||||||
IFG-IGT: 11.4% | ||||||
Tiftikcioglu et al. (2016) [ | Hospital neurology clinic; Turkey | 30 NGT, 25 IGT | Short-term HRV, Sudomotor function | Not provided | ↓SDNN, CV, TP, LF, LF:HF in IGT | Not provided |
Dimova et al. (2017) [ | Hospital diabetes clinic; Bulgaria | 1,130 NGT, 25 IFG, 102 IGT | 8 Short-term HRV indices | NGT: 12.3% | ↓Sympathetic and parasympathetic spectral indices in IFG and IGT | Age, QTc-i, waist for sympathetic and parasympathetic indices;a DBP, 2 hr BG for sympathetic indicesa |
IFG: 13.2% | ||||||
IGT: 20.6% |
Study | No. and type | CAN testing | Follow-up, yr | Kidney function outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|
Sundkvist et al. (1993) [ | 35 T1DM | DB, Tilt test | 10 | CAN predictor of D GFR and associated with ↓GFR |
Weinrauch et al. (1998) [ | 26 T1DM with proteinuria | DB, LS, VM | 1 | VM predictor of D creatinine and renal failure |
Burger et al. (2002) [ | 23 T1DM with macroalbuminuria | DB, LS, VM, HRV indices | 1 | HRV indexes associated with D GFR ≥8 mL/min |
Forsen et al. (2004) [ | 58 T1DM | DB, Tilt test, OH | 7–14 | DB associated with 14 years UAE OH predictor of 7 years D GFR |
Astrup et al. (2006) [ | 388 T1DM with micro-macroalbuminuria | DB | 10 | DB not predictor of D GFR |
Maguire et al. (2007) [ | 137 T1DM with normoalbuminuria | Pupillary light test | 12 | Small pupil size predictor of micro |
Kim et al. (2009) [ | 156 T2DM with normoalbuminuria | DB, LS, VM, OH | 9 | DB predictor of D eGFR |
Brotman et al. (2010) [ | 13,241 (1,523 with diabetes) | Heart rate, HRV indices | 16 | Heart rate and HRV predictors of ESRD |
Tahrani et al. (2014) [ | 204 T2DM without ESDR | DB, LS, VM, OH | 2.5 | CAN predictor of eGFR decline |
Orlov et al. (2015) [ | 204 T1DM with normoalbuminuria 166 T1DM with microalbuminuria | MCR during DB | 14 | MCR <20 predictor of eGFR loss (odds ratio, 4.09) and of CKD stage ≥3 |
Yun et al. (2015) [ | 755 T2DM without CKD | DB, LS, VM, OH | 9.6 | Confirmed CAN predictor of CKD (hazard ratio, 2.62) |
Toronto Consensus (2011) [ | Position Statement ADA (2017) [ | Position Statement AACE/ACE (2018) [ | SID/AMD Standards (2018) [ | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Symptoms | Screening | Screening | Screening | Screening |
Signs | Screening | Screening | Screening | Screening |
CARTs | Gold standard for diagnosis | Possible utility in asymptomatic patients | Screening | Diagnosis |
HRV (time- and frequency-domain indices) | Prognostic information | Research | Clinical use in addition to CARTs | Research |
Candidates | Universal screening of symptoms and signs | Those with microvascular complications and/or hypoglycaemia unawareness | Those with T2DM from diagnosis, or T1DM after 5 years | In particular in those with high CV risk and complications |
Study | Design | Population | Methodology | Results | Comments | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BP | Cardiovascular outcomes | |||||
Tofe Povedano et al. (2009) [ | Open-label crossover study | 40 T2DM, hypertensive subjects | Olmesartan 40 mg in the morning or at bedtime | ↓Nighttime =24 hr | Not evaluated | |
16 wk | ||||||
Hermida et al. (2011) [ | Randomized, open-label, blinded end-point study | 448 T2DM, hypertensive subjects | All hypertension medications upon waking or ≥1 at bedtime | ↓Nighttime =24 hr | ↓Mortality and events | 12% risk reduction per each 5 mm Hg decrease in nighttime systolic BP during follow-up |
5.6 yr (MAPEC study) | ||||||
Rossen et al. (2014) [ | Open-label crossover study | 41 T2DM subjects with nocturnal hypertension | Morning or bedtime administration of all antihypertensive drugs | ↓Nighttime ↓24 hr =Daytime | Not evaluated | ↑Morning urinary sodium/creatinine. |
16 wk | ||||||
Hjortkjaer et al. (2016) [ | Randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind crossover study | 24 T1DM subjects with CAN and nondipping | Bedtime versus morning dosing of enalapril 20 mg (plus other medications) | ↑Dipping =BP | Not evaluated | No effects on left ventricular hypertrophy |
24 wk |
CAN, cardiovascular autonomic neuropathy; NGT, normal glucose tolerance; IGT, impaired glucose tolerance; DB, deep breathing; BMI, body mass index; HRV, heart rate variability; BRS, baroreflex sensitivity; LS, lying to standing; OH, orthostatic hypotension; SDNN, standard deviation of NN intervals; IFG, impaired fasting glucose; HF, high-frequency spectral component of heart rate variability; LF, low-frequency spectral component of heart rate variability; RR, coefficient of variation; rMSSD, root means successive square difference; TP, total power of heart rate variability; nu, normalized units; HOMA-I, homeostatic model assessment index; VM, Valsalva manoeuvre; QTc-i, corrected QT interval; DBP, diastolic blood pressure; BG, blood glucose. aVariables found to be related to CAN in multivariate analysis.
CAN, cardiovascular autonomic neuropathy; T1DM, type 1 diabetes mellitus; DB, deep breathing; GFR, glomerular filtration rate; LS, lying to standing; VM, Valsalva manoeuvre; HRV, heart rate variability; OH, orthostatic hypotension; UAE, urinary albumin excretion; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; eGFR, estimated glomerular filtration rate; ESRD, end-stage renal disease; MCR, mean circular resultant; CKD, chronic kidney disease.
CAN, cardiovascular autonomic neuropathy; ADA, American Diabetes Association; AACE, American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists; ACE, American College of Endocrinology; SID, Italian Society of Diabetology; AMD, Italian Association of Clinical Diabetologists; CART, cardiovascular autonomic reflex test; HRV, heart rate variability; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; T1DM, type 1 diabetes mellitus; CV, cardiovascular.
BP, blood pressure; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; MAPEC, Monitorización Ambulatoria para Predicción de Eventos Cardiovasculares; T1DM, type 1 diabetes mellitus; CAN, cardiovascular autonomic neuropathy.