1Department of Internal Medicine, St. Vincent’s Hospital, College of Medicine, The Catholic University of Korea, Seoul, Korea
2Department of Statistics and Actuarial Science, Soongsil University, Seoul, Korea
Copyright © 2024 Korean Diabetes Association
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
Seung-Hyun Ko has been executive editor of the Diabetes & Metabolism Journal since 2022. She was not involved in the review process of this article. Otherwise, there was no conflict of interest.
FUNDING
This research was supported by the Korea National Institute of Health (KNIH) research project (project No. #2024-ER1101-00).
Guideline and subgroups | Group definition | Glycemic target | Clinical consideration |
---|---|---|---|
2023 KDA guideline [50] | |||
General elderly T2DM | HbA1c <7.5% | Consider individualizing treatment based on health status or frailty level. | |
Healthy older adults may maintain similar glycemic goals as younger adults. | |||
In elderly patients with multiple comorbidities and challenging functional impairments, glycemic targets can be tailored. | |||
For patients nearing the end of life, prioritize minimal treatment focused on managing symptoms caused by hyperglycemia. | |||
2024 ADA guideline [49] | |||
Healthy | Few coexisting chronic illnesses, intact cognitive and functional status | HbA1c <7.0%–7.5% | |
Fasting or preprandial glucose 80–130 mg/dL | |||
Bedtime glucose 80–180 mg/dL | |||
Complex/intermediate | Multiple coexisting chronic illnesses or two or more instrumental ADL impairments or mild to moderate cognitive impairment | HbA1c <8.0% | |
Fasting or preprandial glucose 90–150 mg/dL | |||
Bedtime glucose 100–180 mg/dL | |||
Very complex/poor health | LTC or end-stage chronic illnesses or moderate to severe cognitive impairment or two or more ADL impairments | Avoid reliance on HbA1c | Glucose control decisions should be based on avoiding hypoglycemia and symptomatic hyperglycemia. |
Fasting or preprandial glucose 100–180 mg/dL | |||
Bedtime glucose 110–220 mg/dL | |||
2023 EuGMS-EDWPOP [53] | |||
General elderly group | Without frailty or dementia and without significant associated medical comorbidities | HbA1c <7.0%–7.5% | Consider deprescribing antidiabetic medications if the patient’s HbA1c is below 6.5% or below 7.0% in the presence of frailty. |
Older adults with T2DM, especially those with dementia, moderate to severe frailty, significant renal impairment, or high multimorbidity, may benefit from a deprescribing approach. | |||
Older adults with T2DM experiencing frequent hypoglycemia on complex insulin regimens should be reassessed for potential deprescribing. | |||
2019 Endocrine Society [52] | |||
Good health | ≤1 IADL impairment and no ADL impairment | Low risk of hypoglycemia | The glucose targets are flexible within each group based on individual circumstances. |
Intact cognitive status | HbA1c <7.5% | ||
0–2 chronic illnesses | Fasting glucose 90–130 mg/dL | Coexisting chronic illnesses include conditions like osteoarthritis, hypertension, chronic kidney disease stages 1–3, or stroke. | |
Bedtime glucose 90–150 mg/dL | |||
High risk of hypoglycemia | End-stage conditions include terminal cancer, advanced heart failure, and other serious illnesses. | ||
HbA1c 7.0%–7.5% | |||
Fasting glucose 90–150 mg/dL | ADLs include basic activities like bathing, dressing, and eating; IADLs include managing money, shopping, and using the telephone. | ||
Bedtime glucose 100–180 mg/dL | |||
Intermediate health | ≥2 IADL impairment | Low risk of hypoglycemia | |
Mild cognitive impairment or early dementia | HbA1c <8.0% | ||
Fasting glucose 90–150 mg/dL | |||
≥3 chronic illnesses | Bedtime glucose 100–180 mg/dL | ||
High risk of hypoglycemia | |||
HbA1c 7.5%–8.0% | |||
Fasting glucose 100–150 mg/dL | |||
Bedtime glucose 150–180 mg/dL | |||
Poor health | ≥2 IADL impairment | Low risk of hypoglycemia | |
Moderate to severe dementia | HbA1c <8.5% | ||
End-stage illnesses | Fasting glucose 100–180 mg/dL | ||
Long-term care | Bedtime glucose 110–200 mg/dL | ||
High risk of hypoglycemia | |||
HbA1c 8.0%–8.5% | |||
Fasting glucose 100–180 mg/dL | |||
Bedtime glucose 150–250 mg/dL | |||
2019 JDS [54] | |||
Category I | Intact cognitive function | Low risk of hypoglycemia | |
No impairment of ADL | HbA1c <7.0% | ||
High risk of hypoglycemia | |||
Age 65–74 years: HbA1c <7.5% | |||
Age ≥75 years: HbA1c <8.0% | |||
Category II | Mild cognitive impairment to mild dementia | Low risk of hypoglycemia | High-risk of hypoglycemia: use of drugs potentially associated with severe hypoglycemia, e.g., insulin formulation, sulfonylurea, glinides. |
Impairment of instrumental ADL/no impairment of basic ADL | HbA1c <7.0% | ||
High risk of hypoglycemia | In end-of-life care, priority is to be given to preventing significant hyperglycemia and subsequent dehydration and acute complications through appropriate therapeutic measures. | ||
HbA1c 7.0%–8.0% | |||
Category III | Moderate or severe dementia | Low risk of hypoglycemia | For patients categorized as type I, targets can be individualized: <6.0% for those managing well with diet/exercise or medications without side effects, and up to 8.0% if intensifying therapy is challenging. |
Impairment of basic ADL presence of multiple comorbidities or functional impairments | HbA1c <8.0% | ||
High risk of hypoglycemia | For patients categorized as type III, especially those with serious comorbidities, those with poor social support, and those at risk of developing adverse reactions to multi-drug combination therapy, a glycemic target of <8.5% may be allowed. | ||
HbA1c 7.5%–8.5% | |||
2019 Canadian Diabetes Association [55] | |||
Functionally independent | Clinical frailty index 1–3 | HbA1c ≤7.0% | |
Functionally dependent | Clinical frailty index 4–5 | Low risk of hypoglycemia | |
HbA1c <8.0% | |||
High risk of hypoglycemia | |||
HbA1c 7.1%–8.0% | |||
Frail and/or with dementia | Clinical frailty index 6–8 | Low risk of hypoglycemia | |
HbA1c <8.5% | |||
High risk of hypoglycemia | |||
HbA1c 7.1%–8.5% | |||
End of life | Clinical frailty index 9 | HbA1c measurement not recommended. |
T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; KDA, Korean Diabetes Association; HbA1c, glycosylated hemoglobin; ADA, American Diabetes Association; ADL, activity of daily living; EuGMS-EDWPOP, European Geriatric Medicine Society-European diabetes working party for older people; LTC, long-term care; IADL, instrumental activity of daily living; JDS, Japan Diabetes Society.
Guideline and subgroups | Group definition | Glycemic target | Clinical consideration |
---|---|---|---|
2023 KDA guideline [50] | |||
General elderly T2DM | HbA1c <7.5% | Consider individualizing treatment based on health status or frailty level. | |
Healthy older adults may maintain similar glycemic goals as younger adults. | |||
In elderly patients with multiple comorbidities and challenging functional impairments, glycemic targets can be tailored. | |||
For patients nearing the end of life, prioritize minimal treatment focused on managing symptoms caused by hyperglycemia. | |||
2024 ADA guideline [49] | |||
Healthy | Few coexisting chronic illnesses, intact cognitive and functional status | HbA1c <7.0%–7.5% | |
Fasting or preprandial glucose 80–130 mg/dL | |||
Bedtime glucose 80–180 mg/dL | |||
Complex/intermediate | Multiple coexisting chronic illnesses or two or more instrumental ADL impairments or mild to moderate cognitive impairment | HbA1c <8.0% | |
Fasting or preprandial glucose 90–150 mg/dL | |||
Bedtime glucose 100–180 mg/dL | |||
Very complex/poor health | LTC or end-stage chronic illnesses or moderate to severe cognitive impairment or two or more ADL impairments | Avoid reliance on HbA1c | Glucose control decisions should be based on avoiding hypoglycemia and symptomatic hyperglycemia. |
Fasting or preprandial glucose 100–180 mg/dL | |||
Bedtime glucose 110–220 mg/dL | |||
2023 EuGMS-EDWPOP [53] | |||
General elderly group | Without frailty or dementia and without significant associated medical comorbidities | HbA1c <7.0%–7.5% | Consider deprescribing antidiabetic medications if the patient’s HbA1c is below 6.5% or below 7.0% in the presence of frailty. |
Older adults with T2DM, especially those with dementia, moderate to severe frailty, significant renal impairment, or high multimorbidity, may benefit from a deprescribing approach. | |||
Older adults with T2DM experiencing frequent hypoglycemia on complex insulin regimens should be reassessed for potential deprescribing. | |||
2019 Endocrine Society [52] | |||
Good health | ≤1 IADL impairment and no ADL impairment | Low risk of hypoglycemia | The glucose targets are flexible within each group based on individual circumstances. |
Intact cognitive status | HbA1c <7.5% | ||
0–2 chronic illnesses | Fasting glucose 90–130 mg/dL | Coexisting chronic illnesses include conditions like osteoarthritis, hypertension, chronic kidney disease stages 1–3, or stroke. | |
Bedtime glucose 90–150 mg/dL | |||
High risk of hypoglycemia | End-stage conditions include terminal cancer, advanced heart failure, and other serious illnesses. | ||
HbA1c 7.0%–7.5% | |||
Fasting glucose 90–150 mg/dL | ADLs include basic activities like bathing, dressing, and eating; IADLs include managing money, shopping, and using the telephone. | ||
Bedtime glucose 100–180 mg/dL | |||
Intermediate health | ≥2 IADL impairment | Low risk of hypoglycemia | |
Mild cognitive impairment or early dementia | HbA1c <8.0% | ||
Fasting glucose 90–150 mg/dL | |||
≥3 chronic illnesses | Bedtime glucose 100–180 mg/dL | ||
High risk of hypoglycemia | |||
HbA1c 7.5%–8.0% | |||
Fasting glucose 100–150 mg/dL | |||
Bedtime glucose 150–180 mg/dL | |||
Poor health | ≥2 IADL impairment | Low risk of hypoglycemia | |
Moderate to severe dementia | HbA1c <8.5% | ||
End-stage illnesses | Fasting glucose 100–180 mg/dL | ||
Long-term care | Bedtime glucose 110–200 mg/dL | ||
High risk of hypoglycemia | |||
HbA1c 8.0%–8.5% | |||
Fasting glucose 100–180 mg/dL | |||
Bedtime glucose 150–250 mg/dL | |||
2019 JDS [54] | |||
Category I | Intact cognitive function | Low risk of hypoglycemia | |
No impairment of ADL | HbA1c <7.0% | ||
High risk of hypoglycemia | |||
Age 65–74 years: HbA1c <7.5% | |||
Age ≥75 years: HbA1c <8.0% | |||
Category II | Mild cognitive impairment to mild dementia | Low risk of hypoglycemia | High-risk of hypoglycemia: use of drugs potentially associated with severe hypoglycemia, e.g., insulin formulation, sulfonylurea, glinides. |
Impairment of instrumental ADL/no impairment of basic ADL | HbA1c <7.0% | ||
High risk of hypoglycemia | In end-of-life care, priority is to be given to preventing significant hyperglycemia and subsequent dehydration and acute complications through appropriate therapeutic measures. | ||
HbA1c 7.0%–8.0% | |||
Category III | Moderate or severe dementia | Low risk of hypoglycemia | For patients categorized as type I, targets can be individualized: <6.0% for those managing well with diet/exercise or medications without side effects, and up to 8.0% if intensifying therapy is challenging. |
Impairment of basic ADL presence of multiple comorbidities or functional impairments | HbA1c <8.0% | ||
High risk of hypoglycemia | For patients categorized as type III, especially those with serious comorbidities, those with poor social support, and those at risk of developing adverse reactions to multi-drug combination therapy, a glycemic target of <8.5% may be allowed. | ||
HbA1c 7.5%–8.5% | |||
2019 Canadian Diabetes Association [55] | |||
Functionally independent | Clinical frailty index 1–3 | HbA1c ≤7.0% | |
Functionally dependent | Clinical frailty index 4–5 | Low risk of hypoglycemia | |
HbA1c <8.0% | |||
High risk of hypoglycemia | |||
HbA1c 7.1%–8.0% | |||
Frail and/or with dementia | Clinical frailty index 6–8 | Low risk of hypoglycemia | |
HbA1c <8.5% | |||
High risk of hypoglycemia | |||
HbA1c 7.1%–8.5% | |||
End of life | Clinical frailty index 9 | HbA1c measurement not recommended. |
T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; KDA, Korean Diabetes Association; HbA1c, glycosylated hemoglobin; ADA, American Diabetes Association; ADL, activity of daily living; EuGMS-EDWPOP, European Geriatric Medicine Society-European diabetes working party for older people; LTC, long-term care; IADL, instrumental activity of daily living; JDS, Japan Diabetes
Society.